Thursday, October 27

Welcome to Shine A Light On

Image by Christian Uche Bagnall



Welcome to Shine A Light On
- a blog designated for news, events and other goings-on in Sheffield, South Yorkshire. 

We hope to give you a good insight into life in the city and provide a source of information for what is going on around you (if you're already here).

Our writers come from a range of different backgrounds, both locally and internationally with a wide variety of interests. 

If you have any comments or queries, please feel to get in touch.


Enjoy,
Laura Thompson



 











Friday, January 11

Backing the Bantams in virtual reality


Bradford, 13 October 2012. It's an uncharacteristically sunny autumnal afternoon. Perfect for watching a game of football you might think. And I do.
Before traipsing down to the stadium to shout myself hoarse at two teams contesting a Yorkshire derby, I pop into a bar in the heart of Bradford's city centre. Packed inside the pub are passionate fans of the home side, brimming full of local pride.
Amidst the throng that clamours for a pre-match pint, at a table awaiting that heartiest of northern cuisine – a giant Yorkshire Pudding filled with beef and onion gravy – sits one supporter whose love for the Bantams cannot be questioned.
Because of him, and more than a hundred fellow devoted researchers that work for free, Sports Interactive's Football Manager series has become the UK's leading soccer simulation franchise. Every club in the Premier League, Football League and most sides in the two-tier Conference have someone assessing their players. Gamers can play the season out differently on their PCs/MACs.

Profiling Penfold

Tim's two pence

I also asked Tim how he felt Bradford's start to the season was going. Bantams fans click on the audio below to hear his thoughts.
Tim Penfold, 23, has been Football Manager's official Bradford City AFCresearcher since 2008. A Bantams fan since boyhood, Tim recalls his first match was a 3-1 home defeat to Manchester City in the old First Division (now Football League Championship) in March 1997, aged seven. He's regularly attended fixtures since 2001 and been a season ticket holder at the Coral Windows Stadium (better known as Valley Parade) for almost a decade.

How did you become a researcher for Football Manager?

Tim played the series religiously growing up. One day curiosity, coupled with his encyclopaedic knowledge of Bradford City, drove him to offer advice to developers Sports Interactive about the club's players on forums.
"I went to every home game and some away, so I saw City a lot," Tim said. A researcher role for Bradford was then advertised online, he applied and it was his good fortune that the head researcher saw his helpful comments and took him on.

What do Football Manager look for in a researcher?

"They were looking for someone who would rate the players neutrally," Tim explained. That begs the question how challenging is it to be objective?

Devil is in the details

Small touches you may not have noticed in Football Manager are also thanks to the series' dedicated researchers:
  • Bradford fans wave flags or hold banners, all in an attempt to make the match engine authentic.
  • Graphical minutiae even extend to former and unpopular players and coaches.
  • Crowd reactions are programmed in accordingly.
  • Perhaps the ultimate perk of being a researcher is being able to live vicariously in-game.
  • Tim Penfold will appear as the name of a youth player artificially generated.
"It’s always tricky," was his candid answer. Tim highlighted repeated disappointments in recent seasons destroyed any pretensions he might've had about the Bantams. Further, he believes Bradford's struggles at the wrong end of the Football League have improved his objectivity if not his happiness.
And what if a team suddenly strings some good results together? Be careful about getting carried away Tim stressed – that could distort player ratings. Perhaps then a key maxim for football researchers to remember then is form is temporary, but class (or lack thereof) is permanent.
Having an eye for detail separates a good researcher from a great one. A case in point here is noting player appearances, assists, goals, etc. The good researcher pays heed to these, but as we shall see below Tim goes further.

How do you rate players for the series?

It might sound obvious, but there's no substitute for seeing players in the flesh. "The more games you see, the more you can rate a footballer," Tim continued. Going to just a few matches, he explained, would make it difficult to rate a footballer's consistency of performance for example; so seeing fifteen fixtures is a bare minimum.
Researchers receive guidelines about overall ability levels in a certain league, in Bradford's case League Two. Once he's read these, Tim detailed his tasks to me: "I have to work out who are the star players, who aren't and then the individual attributes, strengths and weaknesses".
Tim warns against doing this process the other way round: "You can end up really overrating players if you pick their attributes first… it means you don't take into account weaknesses properly and that’s an important part of the research."
Attributes for footballers in Football Manager are marked out of 20 on a world scale. Everything from shooting to shot-stopping and crossing to clearances must be assessed.

Try it yourself

Fancy being a researcher forFootball Manager?
Sports Interactive are still looking for fans of AFC Bournemouth and Oxford United amongst others to help make future games.
Because Bradford are in the fourth tier of English football that relatively low level of competition must be reflected in their players' in-game stats. If a midfielder is poor at heading for instance, a researcher would only give them a very low rating. Tim suggested no higher than four.

Statistics

Although the goalscoring charts and assists tables provided a basic guide, Tim's view is there’s more involved in assigning attributes than just glancing at these. "You might be underrating [players] because they do things that nobody notices," he added.
Tim cited the example of central midfielder Ritchie Jones and his role in City's starting XI last season: "We won one game in ten without him in the team. If you look at the other stats, he didn't score many, he didn't create many, but what he did was he kept possession."
Returning to the theme of having an eye for detail, he then recalled noticing something about the form of ex-Bantams winger Joe Colbeck during the start of the 2008-09 campaign. The then-Bradford wide player was just smashing crosses into the box for centre forward Peter Thorne rather than getting his head up and providing accurate deliveries.
This posed a problem for Tim. Goals scored were in his expert opinion down to the intelligence of the striker's movement rather than quality on Colbeck's part. It was thus down to Tim’s judgment here to ensure the assisting player creating and the striker converting the chances were both rated fairly.
Bradford City drew 2-2 with York City as we looked on. Credit: Matt Walker

Is there anything new you like in Football Manager 2013?

Tim immediately drew my attention to Classic Mode when I asked him about the series' latest release. with every new title, Football Manager has become more and more complex to play. Tim described this new option as "almost a slimmed-down second version of the game" which reminded him of some of the earlier games he played as a kid.
This back to basics simplicity was echoed in gaming industry giants IGN's review of Football Manager 2013. Tim also mentioned the new Challenge scenarios the game generates and players can also place the sordid world of transfer negotiations in the hands of a Director of Football if they so wish.

by Jamie Clarke

Exploring the Megatron and other Sheffield secrets



Deep underneath Sheffield city centre - below Park Hill, the train station and Ponds Forge - three rivers meet in a Victorian-engineered subterranean cathedral, built to protect the city from devastating floods.
A soaring arc of brick, these huge vaulted tunnels were built in the 1860s as culverts and storm drains for the Sheaf, Don and Porter Brook rivers. They converge in the middle of Sheffield and after heavy rain they would frequently flood the centre of the young industrial city in the nineteenth century.
Better to be safe than sorry, the Victorian spirit of bending nature to their will engineered a series of vast, brick caverns into which the rivers now flow.
Forgotten by everyone, apart from one or two Yorkshire Water engineers, these tunnels have been re-discovered by an intrepid group of people. Calling themselves 'urban explorers' these climbers, photographers, pot-holers and cavers have been trying to access and document some of the built environment's lost wonders.
"I have always had the urge to explore and look beyond the boundaries set down by society," said Freddie Dennington, 22, from Thame in Oxfordshire. "By exploring this can be tied in with art photography but the clincher for me is the pure natural high gained from a good old adrenaline buzz"

Empty and unused

There are roughly 6000 empty buildings in Sheffield. Most are boarded up terraces and semi-detached shells in the housing estates surrounding the city. Some, however, are historic and unique places that tell their own story and show how the city has developed over the years.
The Abbeydale Picture House in Nether Edge is an example of an old, forgotten, derelict building that has stood empty for years and has now been saved and re-opened for the community. However, there are still countless famous Sheffield landmarks that stand completely empty and unused today.
The Hallam Tower Hotel on Fulwood Road has been empty since 2004. It is owned by a building contractor called Hallam Grange Ltd and despite being granted planning permission for a conversion into residential fats in 2009, the building has been left to rot for nearly ten years.

Swinging past

The City Council have decided recently the exterior of the building is an 'eye-sore' and a blight on S10's leafy, stone-built facade. They would prefer it is either cleaned up and sold off as luxury flats or erased from the skyline.
For many locals, however, it is a cherished landmark and reminder of a swinging past. The tower was opened in 1965, just in time for the influx of visitors to Sheffield for the 1966 World Cup, and was a symbol of the city's regeneration into a shiny, modern city. An advert for the Ford Galaxie 500 was filmed outside the new hotel, complete with Twiggy-esque Sixties models sporting futuristic white outfits.
Now it is empty and unused, urban explorers have been inside the building many times and documented how run down the interior has got. If the outside looks shabby, the inside is much worse. Piles of desks, wiring, old forms, mouldy cardboard and pigeon mess lie everywhere. Once you get to the upper floors, however, you are rewarded by stunning views over Sheffield.
Hallam Tower, which is now called Sheffield Holiday Inn West, is owned by a building contractor called Hallam Grange Ltd, which is based on a farm in Bradfield. The director of the company, David William Hague, who is also the director of five other companies at two different addresses, declined to comment on any plans he may have for the building. A planning application to turn the building into residential flats was awarded in 2009 but no significant work has begun.
The old Grosvenor House Hotel is another huge building in Sheffield that has been left empty. Although a lot less glamorous than Hallam Towers in leafy Ranmoor, this City Centre tower block is recognisable to most locals and is widely considered an eye-sore.
"I worked there for 3 years until it shut down in 2010," said Dale Platts, 25, from Sheffield. "To be honest it seemed to be running itself into the ground so I think the owner closed it before it completely lost its reputation."
South Yorkshire Police have been using the building for police dog training, so it is not completely disused, but the sight of a large empty tower block in the middle of a city makes many people's blood boil.
"I just think it's such a shame when you see a a whole tower block empty in the middle of a city centre," said Freddie, who has been an urban explorer for three years and went down into the Megatron last Summer. "If they've lied empty for over two years I think they shoud be opened to the public, for anyone who wants to renovate a room and make it into a studio space, or make a home if they're homeless. Until the owner starts making a use of it it shouldn't be off limits."
Across the road from Grosvenor House Hotel, Telephone House, the old BT building, is three times the size and has been empty since 2010. Rather than being an old hotel, this imposing, square block is remembered by many as somewhere they used to work. A major employer in the city, BT nevertheless kept a high turnover of temporary workers, much like the Dixons call centre in Nunnery Square, and many regard the building in less than affectionate terms.
"Yeah I know people involved in urban exploring who used to work there, so they have a personal connection to a building that's now completely empty," said Freddie. "It's kind of a sad thing. I don't think they necessarily enjoyed their time there but they would love to go back in and see what's happened to it."

Squatting

As well as simple curiosity, a desire to make use of empty buildings, no matter how superficially ugly they are to modern eyes, is the driving force behind the urban explorer movement. Many have been involved in squatting in the past, and the occupation of an old Salvation Army building in the centre of Sheffield by the Occupy movement involved many urban explorers.
"We squatted an old Salvation Army building as part of Sheffield Occupy," said a man who is known as 'Bear' and would not give his real name. "I've been involved in urban exploring for years, so with a few mates it was easy to get in. We re-named it the Citadel of Hope and opened it up to the community as a space where alternative ideas could be shared and solutions to the inequality we see around us could be discussed."
Re-using and sustainability aside, exploring underground tunnels like the Megatron shows the innate curiosity of urban explorers. It would be extremely difficult to make any use of a flooded tunnel, even some of the older tunnels not immediately being used as a storm drain.


Sense of the unknown

Robbie Shone is a world renowned adventure and cave photographer who used to study in Sheffield. He developed his love for the underground world during his time here and can sympathise with the urban explorers desire to re-discover abandoned or hidden places.
"It began as a pastime whilst at Sheffield Uni, something to do at the weekend, then came the photography in the caves as an art and making pictures where there is no light whatsoever," said Robbie. "The appeal is the sense of the unknown. Simple as that. The thought that nobody can tell you what you will find as it has never been seen before. More people have been to the Moon than some of the places I have photographed."
"I was amazed by the press reaction to my photo of the tunnel reflected in the water," he continued. "They deciced a storm drain underneath Sheffield was far more impressive than the world's largest cave chamber in Malaysia, or one of the world's largest natural shafts in China, or the crystal clear waters flowing through arguably the most impressive river cave in the world: Clearwater Cave."
Places like the Megatron are fascinating once they're uncovered for people to see. In a different way, large buildings like Hallam Towers and Telephone House make people who remember them curious because they are no longer in use. Many feel it is a waste to let these buildings stand empty and call for them to be handed over to community groups during the time they are lying derelict. Others argue it is the natural evolution of the urban environment that some buildings out-grow their usefulness and are eventually levelled, or redeveloped.
Urban explorers will always be there to remind us of places people have forgotten. They can lead us to question how the urban environment can be moulded and occupied, without the consent of officials or the profit-making might of construction companies.

by Alex Fenton-Thomas






Thursday, January 3

A day at Sheffield Greentop Youth Circus



Sudden screams are followed by roars of laughter, racing trainers skip on the wooden floor and singing games mix together with chatter. I feel I'm back at my school playground until Lydia, a tiny eight year-old, stumbles towards me high on her stilts and insists I try the spinning plates. Around us, kids ride the unicycle, swing the hula-hoop and juggle. We are at the Sheffield Greentop Youth Circus, a place where learning has never been as fun.
The Greentop Youth Circus opened in 1995 to keep children off the streets in the area of Grimesthorpe, one of the most deprived neighbourhoods of Sheffield. Almost 18 years later, over 6,000 children from all backgrounds participate in the numerous activities the youth circus organises each year in Sheffield.
As Youth circus tutor Trudi Patient explains to me, in the youth circus diversity is a given and integration one of its defining features: “A lot of parents have said that their children wouldn't necessarily be with other children from different backgrounds... It is quite interesting, everybody gets on”, she assures me.
We have agreed to meet each other at a café before I attend two of the youth sessions she runs in Grimesthorpe circus centre and Meersbrook church.
As I listen to her, my curiosity grows. First I ask how are the sessions organised and to my surprise she says that, although there is a basic structure, it is entirely up to the children which skill they want to practice each day.
All right, I think to myself- there is more improvisation than planning in these classes but surely they must have something ready for the Christmas show...
“The show? They are still discussing it”, answers Trudi. “It is completely run by the children. They choose the theme, the music, whether they want to get up in stage, be in charge of the lights or just welcome people at the door.”
“And how many children are there in each group?”, I ask next, hoping to get a straightforward answer.
“Roughly 18 in each session, but we never know. The circus is open access, anybody can walk in off the street and join”, she smiles.
To me, this is completely new. All I did as a child was going to ballet, judo and swimming lessons and, although they were fun, I had to follow a strict set of rules to progress.
I am mesmerized by this new approach to teaching but also a bit sceptical. How can the kids actually learn something under a “we-set-the-rules” philosophy?

The 'invisible benefits' of the circus

Many parents watch their kids play with the circus equipment at Meersbrook church, where a beginners youth session takes place every Wednesday evening.
I sit with them at the end of the room and share the joy of seeing “children being children”, as Pete Bird, a father of two comments. “The circus is a place where kids can be kids again... They get a lot of pressure nowadays. They have to be in school for many hours and perform well. We grade them in almost everything they do and encourage them to be competitive. It is is sometimes too much for them”.
The youth circus sessions are open to children and youngsters from 5 to 18 years-old. They can learn a range of circus skills including juggling, diabolo, plate spinning, stilts, unicycle or tightrope but the circus also has “invisible benefits” for them, as Trudi describes them.
“There are children who are not really good at sports, they're not really good at group games or anything like that and it is wonderful to see how they blossom at the circus. They don't realise it, but they are growing in many ways. They learn how to be persistent, how to engage in group activities, they do some physical activity, they are more creative... and they are having fun!”, she adds with a smile.

An instructive fun day

“If you want to be a clown I'll teach you”, says seven year-old Tulip holding a hulla-hoop.
“Isn't it too hard to learn?”, I ask.
“Well... Sometimes it is easy and you can learn quite fast and then you go and do the hard stuff”, she says with an encouraging smile.
Like her, many children come buzzing around me like flies asking questions and encouraging me to try things.
I stand up and try a bit of hulla-hooping with her. Then, eight year-old Lydia comes on her stilts and insists on teaching me how to spin a plate. As I slowly manage to keep it dancing on top of the stick, I grin from ear to ear, thinking about the most important thing that the youth circus teaches us a wider lesson: that it can be possible to learn by simply having fun.

by Carlota Calderon

Wednesday, January 2

Modern long-distance romantic relationships



Does absence really make the heart grow fonder? Recent surveys suggest that long-distance romantic relationships (LDRRs) are rising in the UK due to a growing use of modern technology. 
The US-based Centre for the Study of LDRs reveals that almost one-fifth of 350 British university students surveyed are involved in LDRRs this year.

10 tips to make modern LDRRs work:

  • Ask the important questions at the onset, to make sure you are both clear on the parameters of the relationship
  • Consider communicating in some way as often as possible
  • Avoid the temptation to control
  • Avoid jealousy and learn to trust
  • Take advantage of distance to cultivate individualism
  • Be positive
  • Pursue common interests, even if it means pursuing them apart
  • Talk about your future together
  • Remember the good times you have spent together
  • Visit often
LDRRs are typically defined as intimate relationships between married or non-married couples who are separated by a considerably geographic distance.
Stephen Blake with over 65,000 copies sold worldwide, says that technological advancements has become an important factor in popularizing LDRRs in the UK.
“We have come a long way from the time when the only communication between long-distance lovers was via telephone or mail. Modern technology enables us to communicate with each other readily and makes today’s LDRRs easier to sustain and flourish,” says Mr Blake.
The current forms of communication frequently employed by couples in LDRRs include phone calls, Voice over Internet Protocol (ProtocolVoIP) programs, e-mails, text messaging, social networking websites and online games (e.g.MMORPGs).
CJun Lin has been in LDRRs for 3 years since he arrived in Sheffield for undergraduate study.
He says: “The Internet helps to bridge the physical distance like never before. Sending roses to my sweetie in Beijing can be done at the click of a button on the online florist...We often make video calling with Skype to share our feelings and comfort each other…I have confidence in our love.”
Rady Rana from the Sheffield Hallam University has a close relationship with a man she has never actually met face to face.
Miss Rana says: “I met Toni via Facebook…Facebook messages went to MSN…MSN went to Skype video calls…Destiny took its toll, as it does…We have become a really good couple and we are making plans to meet up.”
Modern LDRRs seems to have challenged the convention that physical proximity is the dynamic of intimate relationships.
Can Internet dating really meet what a couple needs to maintain their relationship?
“I’ve met many couples in modern LDRRs who started with happiness but ended in frustration if they had not taken the bold step to face the real look of their honeys’ life or one of them had tried to control the other,” says Mr Blake.
In fact, the key to successful modern LDRRs is not proximity but a true compatibility. The Centre for the Study of LDRs finds that the frequency of break ups in modern LDRRs is not greater than that in geographically proximal romantic relationships (PRRs). This suggests that our needs from romantic relationships are more emotional and psychological than physical.
Mr Blake points out that distance cannot, and will not hurt a bond between a couple which is based on mutual respect, trust, commitment and love.
He also offers 10 pieces of advice to make modern LDRRs work.

by Jiawen Zhou

Tuesday, January 1

Online essay mills targeting Chinese students



Kexin Lee is a 36-year-old man from Southern China,. He has never had college education and can hardly speak any English, but when it comes to essay writing, hundreds of Chinese students in the UK turn to Lee with their essay tasks, paying him from £100 to £300 per thousand words.
Lee then assigns the made-to-order tasks his ghostwriters in China and pays them as little as £20 per thousand words.
Since it was founded in 2006, Lee’s business has grown steadily responding to ever growing demand. “I never want to change my job”, said Lee, “my wife and I ran the business together, now we own a car and an apartment”.
I contacted Lee posing as a Chinese student in want of a job. After filling out a form about my education background, I was given my first task: a 500 words business essay for a student who studies in a University in the UK. I was supposed to write the essay in three days according to the guidelines given to me, and then send the piece back to the student, who can then hand it in to the school.
When we contacted the student he was buying in the essays to get better marks. We are not using his name to protect his identity.
“Half of the times I buy my essays online”, said the student, “but the difference is not big. For example, if I write my own essay, I may get 55%, if its done by someone else I may get 60%, approximately.”
“But I didn’t have enough time to write my essays, I am lazy, and I am in my third year, I want better marks”.
“In general, the essay done by the others gain better marks.”

Blooming business 

essay
Website of an essay company
Lee is only a minor player in the massive online essay trading industry.
“Essay trading has exceeded £200 million”, said BBC China, in an article published on BBC Mandarin site in March, 2011.
A brief search on Google in Chinese for “overseas essay writing service”  provides six results of such nature.
Wang XueFeng, from lunwenmarket.com , said:  “We have been in the business for eight years, and we have more than 700 essay writers internationally.  Hundreds of students come to us each month.”
“All our essays are carefully crafted by our writers, we guarantee no plagiarism, we never had a problem with turnitin.”
Turnitin is a internet-based plagiarism-prevention service used by many universities in the UK.
However, another student from told me he once order an essay from an online essay mill, but it could not meet the originality level required by the university, he did not get his money back.
Many international online essay mills are also targeting Chinese students.
“We are an international essay company”, said David Hall from the customer service at SuperiorEssay.com. “We have lots of Chinese clients, we receive orders almost everyday from Chinese students”.
Another company based in Arnold, Nottingham, UK, has a Chinese website which says: “essay writers will deliver you a unique, original essay through our confidential customer service system after sufficient reading and researching”.
It is cheating
Essay services have different opinions on whether buying essay from them is cheating.
“I am sure it is not illegal, it is a grey area in law”, said Wang XueFeng, from lunwenmarket.com. “of course it is cheating, but who doesn’t?”
“Students can submit the essay to their universities, we will do the essay for them, but it will be their ideas, we will follow all the instructions, so it is not cheating.” said David Hall.
Martiz Carline, the customer service manager from the UKEssay, said:” cheating is not our purpose”.
He continued, “the student is not meant to hand that in, or copy from  or plagiaries from the work we have done in anyway, but they can look at how we have done it in terms of research, academic sources, structure and so on. The students use our work as a guide, read through what we have done that gives them inspiration, and go on creating their own original piece of work.”
“We have a fair use policy on our website,”, said Martiz Carline, “but we cannot stop student from using the service incorrectly”.
However, most universities in the UK, using other’s work is cheating. For example, according to the Academic Discipline of the University of Sheffield, “submitting bought or commissioned work for example from internet sites, essay "banks" or "mills" is an extremely serious form of plagiarism.” and it says for students who does this, “the University may impose penalties ranging from awarding a grade of zero for the assignment through to expulsion from the University in extremely serious cases”.
“The University has a very strict procedure in dealing with cheating” said Chris Stratford, a tutor from the University of Sussex, “but we have to have hard evidence to prove the misconduct, and it is proved, the university disciplinary board will make a decision.
“I think if a student is caught using purchased essay, he or she will be thrown out of the university.
“but it is very difficult to detect plagiarism in such way, we have no evidence of such misconduct yet, though we have had cases where people have taken from student websites, and we have a blacklist of about 20 sites that we check.” Added Stratford.

by Chloe Chen

Thursday, December 20

How the internet turned the tables on the high street bookmaker



In a city centre bookmaker on a Friday afternoon, old men huddle around a table studying battered form cards while a couple of students frantically tick various boxes of a football coupon for some obscure league. The rest cluster around high stakes roulette machines as £10 notes are stuffed into them as if they were toilet paper. Somewhere amongst this crowd is an altogether different type of punter. A punter who does not see gambling as risk versus reward but rather as strictly business and has no intention of losing.
The advent of online betting exchanges, such as Betfair and Betdaq, has made this achievable. It is now possible to not only back an outcome to win, but also back the same outcome to lose (or "laying”) on the exchanges. For the shop punter it means that betting is no longer just about backing something in the hope it might win, but finding selections that he can back and lay simultaneously to guarantee a profit whatever the outcome. This is known as arbitrage betting.
An arbitrage bet, also known as an arb, is relatively easy to spot in theory. If the odds for the back bet are higher than those of the lay bet then there is money to be made. Whatever the outcome, the profit will always be greater than the amount staked on both bets.
Bookmakers, such as William Hill, move quickly to close the accounts of anyone they suspect of arbitrage as it is against their terms of use, unfair and unprofitable. A spokesman for William Hill says that typically those involved in arbitrage, and who are known simply as "arbers”, only operate online. They use state of the art software to spot potential profitable price differences between a bookmaker's online market and an exchange. Stakes are in the thousands of pounds for each bet yet only a small percentage profit is made each time as the smallest price differences are exploited.
According to the William Hill spokesman, shop arbers, or sharbers, are seen as less of a concern in comparison. They are difficult to spot and bets placed in shops are typically in far smaller amounts meaning that profits are not as great.
However, bookmakers are now more prominent than ever on British high streets. Ladbrokes announced in August that they would add 60 more shops to their current total of 2150 by the end of 2012. Whilst William Hill leads the way with nearly 2400 retail outlets across the UK. This means that although individual bet stakes are smaller, the total staked by a shop arber can still be sizable.
Profits made from sharbing depend on a number of variables such as time and how much is staked on each bet. However, those involved in shop arbitrage claim they can typically make between £40 to £200 each week.

Low tech affair

Shop arbitrage is also a far less high tech affair. The comfort of an office with multiple screens highlighting price differences is swapped for walking or cycling in all elements to various chains of betting shops. Spotting price differences is not an automatic affair either. It involves picking up various coupons and manually comparing each price with the price available at the exchange via a smartphone or laptop with wireless connection.
The task is a time consuming one as individuals travel between various bookmakers. A midweek fixture list regularly contains over 60 matches from leagues across Europe. Each firm will have their own coupon and their own odds meaning that this task is multiplied for each new set of matches. Even when a suitable selection has been found the odds at the exchange or the bookmaker can disappear in an instant and render the selection useless. Sharbing therefore can often be a frustrating and anti-social pursuit as hours can be wasted on fruitless trips.

Mobile evolution

However, the evolution of mobile technology means that sharbing is now more accessible than ever. Anyone can pick up their smartphone and learn how to place arbitrage bets. Websites such as Bet72.com walk through the maths and principles behind "risk free betting". While calculators, such as Betvault, produce figures for bets in order to guarantee a profit and can be downloaded free as apps meaning that little understanding of the maths behind betting is needed. Sharbers can also access mobile platforms of online betting exchanges in shops. Any risk of an unfavourable swing in the odds between placing the bet in shop and the one at the exchanges is therefore negated.
Sharbing is an individual pursuit and interaction between sharbers takes place almost exclusively on internet forums. They will swap tales and occasionally tips with one another behind the anonymous veil of a username. Intermittently a few reveal details of their occupations. Their backgrounds are varied with housewives, students, call centre workers and executives all claiming to dabble in shop arbitrage. However, many appear paranoid that bookmakers are actively searching forums for information to identify them. They rarely disclose their location, names or shops that they frequent.

Refuse bets

Anonymity is vital, as being recognised by shop staff would almost certainly mean an end to the profitable pastime. Cash is used in order to make transactions untraceable between shops. Profiles are kept low as they study pages of the Racing Post pinned to the walls, watch greyhound racing on a wall of screens and look over various coupons in attempt to blend in with ‘mug punters'. If a sharber is identified then staff can limit stakes, offer a lower price or refuse the bet outright.
In Sheffield city centre opportunities for sharbing are never more than a few streets away. From Castle Market to the Moor there are 10 betting shops whilst there are five within 100 yards of Castle Market itself.
'Tony S' is in his late 30s and a senior manager in the education sector. He has been sharbing around South Yorkshire for the past 12 months to provide a supplementary income and devotes around two to three hours a week to travelling between betting shops. He began sharbing after having a number of his online betting accounts closed.
He has encountered his own problems when placing arbitrage bets but believes arbing in shop rather than online has advantages: "I don't actively disguise my appearance, although I have made the odd effort with my jacket or glasses on or off. If they try hard they will use CCTV and there's not much you can do about that unless you put a hat or hood on which will only attract attention anyway.
"I'm not sure I was specifically recognised as a sharber – but once I placed an unusually (for that shop location presumably) high bet on a price boost, and the cashier phoned through to a nearby shop which I then strolled in to only to be recognised and offered at a lower price. I've had limits on arbs also, but I think these were general rather than personal.”
"There is potential to get more money on specific arbs and offers than with a single online account. When accounts are closed online, shops may be the only way to get money on.”

Not risk free

While arbitrage betting is often hailed as a risk free way of producing a supplementary or even secondary income, there are potential pitfalls as one Yorkshire sharber, known as 'The Phantom Wheeler', highlights: "The downsides are carrying large wads of cash and misplacing betting slips. I once lost my wallet containing around £300 in cash and betting slips.”
'The Phantom Wheeler', a call centre worker in his late 40s, cycles up to 35 miles between shops, and has been sharbing for the past four years. He says that he spends around two hours a week sharbing and expects to make around £40.
Despite his mishap he still recommends it as a way of providing a secondary income: "I sharb in order to enjoy luxuries that I could otherwise not afford.
"It gets me out of the house, gives me an adrenalin rush, keeps me fit and I like to get one over on the bookies.
"It's good fun, although not as lucrative as it once was, but it's still worthwhile in my honest opinion.”
'Tony S' does not share the same view. "It's difficult to say if I'd recommend it. I probably wouldn't to be honest.”
"The downsides are time and, although I've never had any problems myself, I'm not sure a lot of cash in my pocket and some bookie clients is always a good mix if you see what I mean!”
Shop arbitrage will continue for as long as the punter can stay ahead of the bookmaker.
The evolution of technology and the anonymity of the bookmaker shop means that currently the advantage is with punter. Betting firms are aware that information on how to take advantage of them is freely available on the internet and that identifying sharbers is still an incredibly difficult task. Bookmakers make their money from beating the punter and they will hope to find a way to turn the tables back soon.

by Alistair McCloskey